Columbus in 1492: Oops, Not Asia, Just the Bahamas

By Bananaking – for HistoryGoneBananas

On this day in 1492, Christopher Columbus made landfall on an island he named San Salvador. The catch? He thought he was in Asia. In reality, he had reached the Bahamas, bumping into an entirely new chapter of global history by accident. Historians call it a turning point, but let’s be honest: it’s one of the world’s biggest, most consequential wrong turns.

Columbus set sail west from Spain with a bright idea: reach Asia faster by sailing across the Atlantic. He miscalculated the Earth’s size (ignoring math that already said otherwise), and instead of spices and silk, he found islands, seashells, and some very confused Taíno locals.

His crew? Just glad they didn’t mutiny.
Columbus? Convinced he was near Japan.
History? About to be rebranded forever.

Pinpointing Columbus’s first landing is a mini mystery on its own. Most scholars identify Watling Island (modern San Salvador Island, Bahamas). Others argue for Samana Cay or Conception Island. Basically, history’s most hyped landfall doesn’t even have a confirmed GPS location. Classic.

Even faced with glaring evidence, Columbus refused to admit this was not Asia. His logs described friendly island natives as potential converts and—tellingly—future laborers. Instead of accidentally founding tourism in the Bahamas, he set the stage for colonization and exploitation. Truly the original “refuse to ask for directions” guy.

Columbus did not “discover” the Americas—indigenous peoples had lived there for millennia. But his voyages launched the so-called Age of Discovery, which meant massive cultural exchange... and massive destruction. Celebrated in Europe, catastrophic in the Caribbean. It’s a legacy historians, educators, and critics continue to grapple with today.

In 1492, Columbus thought he had reached Asia, but instead he opened the door to a brand-new hemisphere for European empires. He promised exotic trade—delivered palm trees and coconuts. One of the costliest “oops” moments in history? Absolutely. A global game-changer? Without question.

Love banana-flavored history that’s fun and fact-packed? Support HistoryGoneBananas by subscribing to our newsletter, following us on socials, and sharing this story with your fellow history nerds. Let’s make sure Columbus isn’t the only one going viral.

Q1: What date did Columbus land in the New World?
Columbus first landed on October 12, 1492 (Old Style calendar: October 21). He named the island San Salvador, part of today’s Bahamas.

Q2: Why did Columbus call the island San Salvador?
He named it San Salvador (“Holy Savior”) to honor God and claim the territory for Spain. The name also helped frame his voyage as a spiritual mission, not just a business venture.

Q3: Did Columbus know he discovered America?
No. Columbus thought he had reached islands off the coast of Asia. He believed this until his death in 1506, never realizing he encountered a “New World.”

Q4: Which island was Columbus’s San Salvador?
Most historians point to Watling Island, now officially San Salvador Island in the Bahamas. Alternative theories include Samana Cay and Conception Island.

Q5: Why is Columbus’s landing controversial?
While often celebrated as discovery, Columbus’s arrival began a period of colonization, forced labor, disease outbreaks, and cultural destruction among indigenous peoples.

Q6: What can modern readers learn from Columbus 1492?
The landing teaches us the impact of mistaken assumptions, the power of narrative framing, and how a single voyage reshaped global history for centuries.